Comprehensive guide to transport options for seamless travel
City Center
Fish Creek
1.0
mi
Airports
Austin Straubel International (GRB)
74.3
mi
Delta County (ESC)
174.4
mi
Facilities
The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences
Cozy Comfort
“The room was equipped with a kitchenette and a fireplace, adding a cozy touch that made our stay feel like home.” view full review
Relaxing Retreat
“The on-site lavender spa offered wonderful services that helped me unwind after a busy day of exploring.” view full review
Perfect Kitchenette
“Having a well-stocked kitchenette was a game-changer for us, allowing us to enjoy local produce comfortably in our room.” view full review
Inviting Space
“The living area had a deep sofa and a homely atmosphere that was perfect for curling up with a good book in the evenings.” view full review
General
Non-smoking property
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Front desk
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
Fireplace
Guest Parking
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Services
Laundry
Tours/Ticket assistance
Stores/Commercial services
Dining
Breakfast
Outdoor dining area
Picnic area/ Tables
Coffee/Tea in lobby
Free breakfast
Facilities for people with disabilities
Bathroom for disabled
Spa & Leisure
Outdoor swimming pool
Barbeque grills
Television in lobby
Spa center
Room features
Free Wi-Fi in rooms
Sitting area
Dressing area
Terrace
Tea and coffee facilities
Dining table
Bathroom
Free toiletries
Self-catering
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Media
Flat-screen TV
CD player
Room decor
Carpeted floor
Show more
Location
9126 State Hwy 42,
Fish Creek,
Wisconsin,
United States of America,
54212,
Wisconsin
Map view
9126 State Hwy 42,
Fish Creek,
Wisconsin,
United States of America,
54212,
Wisconsin
City landmarks
Parks
Peninsula State Park
1.9
mi
4147 Main St
Santa Fe Shop
1.4
mi
Museums
Historic Noble House
1.4
mi
4175 Main St
J. Jeffrey Taylor
1.4
mi
Gallery
Edgewood Orchard Galleries
1.6
mi
Gallery
Hide Side Corner Store
1.4
mi
9415 Cottage Row
Church of the Atonement
1.4
mi
9462 State Highway 42
Fish Creek Public Beach
1.4
mi
Gallery
Interfibers Studio Gallery
2.2
mi
Gallery
Connie Glowacki Artist
2.2
mi
Broadway Theatre
Door Community Auditorium
2.3
mi
3655 Peninsula Players Rd
Hands On Art Studio
2.4
mi
Broadway Theatre
Northern Sky Gould Theater
2.5
mi
Lighthouse
Eagle Bluff Lighthouse
3.8
mi
4234 County Rd E
Off The Wheel Pottery
4.1
mi
Peninsula State Park
Eagle Tower
4.1
mi
Nearby
Winery
Lautenbach's Orchard Country Winery & Market
1300 ft
Restaurants
Sweetie Pie's
600 ft
9106 Wisconsin Route 42
Reviews and Ratings
Reviews from guests about their experience.
88%
loved their spa retreat and can’t wait to return.
8.8/10
Great
Rooms
7.8
Location
8.4
Service
5.8
Dining
5.8
Guest reviews
8.8/10
based on 5 reviews
8.6
8.6/10 based on 29 reviews
Rachel
United States of America,
February
2025
6.2/10
I had a mixed experience at the inn. On the plus side, the spacious rooms with the warm crackling fireplace created a cozy atmosphere, and the spa services were fantastic. However, a lack of cleanliness in the Coach House and unkind management during a difficult personal time left a sour note. Overall, it's a charming place with potential, but there are definitely areas for improvement.
Rooms
8.0
The rooms were spacious with a lovely gas fireplace which made for a cozy stay. I appreciated having the option for daily service or just linen exchanges.
Service
5.0
While the initial interactions with the staff were warm, my experience regarding my reservation cancellation due to a family emergency was disappointing.
Location
9.0
The inn is surrounded by beautiful wineries and has a lovely outdoor seating area. It’s well-positioned for exploring the charming sights of the area.
Dining
6.0
The continental breakfast was decent, with a variety of breads and some pastries, but I hoped for a bit more local flavor and options.
Facilities
5.0
The inn featured great facilities like a spa which had impressive services. However, the cleanliness of some areas could use some attention.
Ed
United States of America,
January
2025
6.8/10
My stay at Settlement Inn was quite the experience. The rooms were spacious with charming features, which made the ambiance cozy, especially with the inviting fireplaces. Unfortunately, the spa experience didn’t quite live up to my expectations; the setup left something to be desired. Still, the location is wonderful, providing easy access to local attractions, and the overall value for what I paid was decent.
Rooms
8.0
The rooms were spacious, featuring a kitchenette complete with a full-size fridge, making it very convenient for longer stays. They were also very inviting, just as shown in the online photos.
Service
6.0
While my experience with service was adequate, I did encounter some disappointing moments with the management during a personal crisis. However, the general staff around were often attentive and seemed eager to help.
Location
9.0
The inn is ideally located, allowing easy access to various local attractions while still feeling secluded enough to relax. It's perfect for anyone looking to explore Door County.
Dining
7.0
Breakfast was simple and included fresh items from a local bakery, although I had hoped for a bit more variety. However, enjoying breakfast by the fireplace made it feel special.
Facilities
5.0
The spa facilities were not as relaxing as I had expected; the atmosphere lacked charm and felt more like a hotel room. I think they could improve by creating a more inviting space.
Andrew
United States of America,
December
2024
6.2/10
Our stay at the hotel had its highlights and drawbacks. The room was spacious and we enjoyed the pleasant outdoor areas, but the dining options left much to be desired. The massage experience was disappointing, and while the staff was attentive, the overall service could use improvement.
Rooms
7.0
The room was spacious and well-equipped with a fridge and microwave, but the TV was broken, which was a letdown.
Service
5.0
While the staff was friendly and helpful, my experience at the spa was disappointing due to the quality of the massage.
Location
8.0
The hotel was in a quiet location that felt peaceful and secluded, ideal for relaxation.
Dining
5.0
Breakfast was simple, with hard boiled eggs and some pastries, but not very appealing if you're looking for variety.
Facilities
6.0
The hotel had nice outdoor areas and recreational options like a pool and grills, but the spa service could improve significantly.
Lisa
United States of America,
October
2024
7.6/10
I had a lovely stay at this charming inn, where the focus on tranquility and relaxation was evident. My room was spacious and comfortable, complete with a cozy gas fireplace, which added a warm touch to the ambiance. Although the breakfast was adequate, I would have preferred more variety, especially protein options. The outdoor pool was great for a refreshing dip after a day of exploring, but the navigational challenges on the bike trails could use some improvement.
Rooms
9.0
The rooms were spacious and featured a lovely gas fireplace, creating a comfortable atmosphere.
Service
7.0
The service was decent, with staff available for assistance during our stay.
Location
8.0
The inn was conveniently located near Fish Creek, providing easy access to local attractions while maintaining a peaceful setting.
Dining
6.0
Breakfast was decent with fresh bakery items and cereals, but lacked protein variety.
Facilities
8.0
The outdoor pool was well-maintained and inviting for enjoyable leisure time.
Ray
United States of America,
September
2024
7.0/10
The inn has a charming atmosphere with spacious rooms and unique features like an outdoor patio and various recreational options. While the cleanliness and comfortable ambiance were appreciated, the lack of entertainment during rainy evenings and a less-than-stellar breakfast were downsides to consider. Overall, it offers a decent getaway experience, but be prepared for some limitations on amenities.
Rooms
7.0
The rooms are spacious and comfortable, featuring thoughtful amenities such as a kitchenette and a fireplace. However, the mattress was harder than I expected.
Service
8.0
The service was warm and welcoming, with staff willing to help out and provide suggestions.
Location
8.0
The location is relatively secluded yet conveniently situated, allowing easy access to nearby attractions.
Dining
5.0
The continental breakfast was adequate, offering basic options that didn’t really showcase the local flavors.
Facilities
7.0
The facilities were decent, with a nice outdoor area for relaxation and recreational activities such as a pool and grills for guest use.